Document

IN A NUTSHELL

the animal research

Every scientific project requering vertebrates (mammals, birds, fishes, reptiles or amphibians) and also the fœtal or embryonic forms of mammals or cephalopods must be allowed by the ministry of research.
A referral must be deposited to be evaluated by the ethics committee of animal testing. The permission is applicable for 5 years.

In 1959, the british William M. S. Russell and Rex L. Burch defined the 3R rule (reduce, refine, replace) which currently governs the ethical obligations supervising animal testing.

Reduce : Each experience is thought to reduce the number of animal used and in particular by :
- limiting the repetition of the experience
- redaction of a protocol concerning all experience
- only conducting essential experiments
- sharing animals, tissues or organs taken from the animal between colleagues working on related fields
- using statistic tools to define previously the bare minimum of animals necessary in each experiments to obtain exploitable results

Replace : It is the main goal today. As soon as possible, whether a replacement method like in vitro (cellular) model or in silico (informatic modelisation) model exists, it would be done.

Rehome It is the fourth «R». This recent concept encourages the retirment of the animals at the end of the experiments. It is not a requirment but only an authorization for some animals that do not represent any danger for the public health, the animal health or the environment.

There is an other important concept which is the limit point. Before each experimentation on an animal model, limit points of suffering are established and set the factors defining the end of the study.

In 2015, the Graal association has rehomed more than 500 dogs, 50 horses, 30 monkeys and many fishes.

In France, animal research uses 2,2 millions of animal each year, the equivalent of 1 animal per 30 persons/year.

70% of the studies done by the public research in France are made on in vitro models or in a other word on cellular models.

THE NOBEL PRICES

According to Nobel's testament, the Nobel price of medecine and physiology rewards, since 1901, scientists that have brought a real benefit to the humanity thanks to their works. This can include both knowledge and technical breakthrough.
Of the 106 Nobel prices awarded since 1901, 76 are directly linked to results reliying on animal testing.

1901

E.A. von Behring

Discovery of the Diphteria antitoxin

Animal: Guinea Pig

Bacteriology

R. Koch

Study on Tuberculosis

Animal: Cow and Sheep

Bacteriology

1905

1907

C.L.A. Laveran

Study on protozon parasites responsible for malaria

Animal: Bird

Parasitology

A. Carrel

Works on vasculary sutures and vessels or organs transplant

Animal: Dog

Medical Technology

1912

1923

F.G.Banting & J.J.R. Macelod

Discovery of Insuline

Animal: Rabbit,Dog and Fish

Endocrinology

W. Einthoven

Discovery of electrocardiogram

Animal: Dog

Medical Technology

1924

1932

C.S. Sherrington,E.D. Adrian

Discovery of neurons function

Animal: Cat and Dog

Neurosciences

A.Fleming,E.B.Chain

Discovery of Penicillin

Animal: Mouse

Bacteriology

1945

1954

J.F. Enders, T.H. Weller

Discovery of polio virus culture

Animal: Mouse and Monkey

Virology

A.M. Cormack

Development of computer-assisted tomography,the source of scanner.

Animal: Pig

Medical Technology

1979

1985

M.S. Brown

Discovery of regulatory mechanisms for cholestrol metabolism

Animal: Rat

Metabolism

the alternatives...

60% of the animals used for experiments are employed for
fundamental research. Today, to limit their sacrifice, some alternatives exist

In Vitro Models

Literally « in vitro » means « in the glass ». This expression indicates that all experiments are done in a test tube which means that they are done outside of a living organism. It might be activity assays conducted on isolated cell lines or tests done on specific proteins. For example, these preliminary studies are essential to caracterize the activity of potential novel drugs on a specific receptor.

Healthy or sick post-mortem tissus extracted from humans or animals

The assays performed on cell lines are also considered as in vitro experiments. In this case, the model is more integrated because it concerns cells that can interact among themselves. Today, many cell lines obtained from human cells are in development and further caracterization.

Ex Vivo Model

In cellular biology, ex vivo models refers to tissues or organs extracted from a living organism and which have been cultivated. This kind of methods requires a smaller sacrifice from the animal in comparison with in vivo experiments that are directly performed on the living animal.

Healthy or sick post-mortem tissus extracted from humans or animals

Sampling post-mortem tissue in the hospital from healthy or sick persons allows important discoveries and studies. The Neuro-CEB for example, is a cerebral tissue bank which was created for the research on Parkinson disease since 2002. This collection is made from healthy or unhealthy donors and allows a better understanding of the disease's physiopathology.

Animal Models

Here, a non exhuastive list reviews some animal models that are more or less frequently used for fundamental or applied research.

0%

C.Elegans

Nematod (about 1 mm) – Invertebrate

Neuroscience++

0%

Drosphila

Drosophila Melanogaster - Invertebrate

Biology of development and anatomy

60.9%

Mouse

Mus musculus

Research on infectious or immune diseases or cancer

12.47%

Zebra-Fish

Danio reiro

Cell biology

12.47%

Xenopus

Xenopus Laevis/Xenopus Tropicalis

Antibacterial research

3.12%

Rabbit

New Zealand albino with pink eyes

Heart, lungs and blood circulation study

0.25%

Dog

Especially Beagle breed

Endocrinology

0.05%

Primate

Macaque

Psychology and behaviour study

CONCLUSION

Animal experiments are conducted in all medical disciplines for the investigation of new biomaterials, therapeutic interventions, and drugs. Ethical committees and regulatory authorities generally request animal experiments prior to the initiation of clinical trials in humans. While cell cultures allow for assessment of the cytotoxicity of novel biomaterials or drugs, there is a preference for small animal models to investigate complex immunological reactions and to guarantee the safety of new therapeutic interventions.